The Portfolio Committee on Justice and Constitutional Development has called for changes to legislation in order to prevent magistrates from escaping accountability by resigning before their disciplinary proceedings are finalised.

This comes amid mounting concerns over the millions of rands paid to suspended judicial officers who are away from work for years while their disciplinary matters drag on. This was one of the concerns raised by the Portfolio Committee following an update from the Magistrates Commission earlier this week on several disciplinary matters. The briefing covered various convoluted disciplinary processes that have been ongoing for several years, the financial implications of suspensions and the Commission’s inability to fill positions occupied by suspended magistrates.

The committee heard that several magistrates have resigned while facing disciplinary proceedings, including Bloemfontein regional magistrate Mr L Mkansi, Umlazi regional magistrate Ms K Bodlani, Kimberley magistrate Ms N Naude, Gqeberha magistrate Ms A Beeton and Ezakheni magistrate Ms L Vakalisa.

According to the committee, resignations often occur when a finding is imminent or has already been established. Committee Chairperson Mr Xola Nqola said: “They decide to just resign as part of evading the recommendations of their disciplinary hearing.”

The Chairperson stressed that legislative intervention was likely the way forward to address such conduct. He said this is a loophole that allows judicial officers to leave public service with their financial benefits intact while completely evading the finalisation of formal accountability procedures. “This also usually comes after magistrates have been on suspension for years with full benefits. The cost to the state is enormous.”

The committee noted that Mr Mkanazi received more than R7.36 million during his suspension from May 2020 until his resignation, including seven months after his criminal conviction and sentence. Meanwhile, Ms Bodlani cost taxpayers R8 million before her resignation this year. She was suspended in July 2020.

The chief state law adviser has recommended that relevant existing laws be reviewed and considered for amendment.

The committee also raised concerns about magistrates who remain suspended for extended periods, with some continuing to receive salaries despite being away from their posts. These included Lenyenye district court magistrate Ms R Govender, Pietermaritzburg senior magistrate Mr A Singh, KwaZulu-Natal regional court president Mr E Nzimande, Secunda district court magistrate Mr TK Kekana and Booysens magistrate Ms ESS Fredericks.

Mr Nqola said this affected both the administration of justice and state finances, while preventing the filling of positions that remained occupied. “The danger of them delaying is that they are paying judicial officers that are not at work and also unable to appoint or hire someone else because that position would not have been vacant. So, it has got a double impact both on the operations and dispensation of justice and also in the national fiscus,” the Chairperson remarked.

The committee further recommended that the National Assembly withhold the remuneration of Ms Fredericks whilst she is on suspension and also agreed not to recommend her reinstatement. She has been absent from work without permission since November 2019 and the disciplinary processes against her have dragged on for years. The committee also recommended that Ms Kekana’s salary be withheld after her suspension in March 2025.

Committee member Mr Damien Dominic Klopper wanted to know why it has taken so long despite Parliament having dealt with the Fredericks matter previously. “There’re many unanswered questions of how someone doesn’t attend court for five years,” he stated.

Another committee Member, Ms Mathibe Mohlala, added to this concern and wanted to know why so many years pass before taking decisions on certain issues. “There are a lot of issues that show that we have a problem actually in terms of Magistrates Commission because it is not handling issues as they are supposed to be.”

The disciplinary cases against Mr Singh, suspended in December 2023, and Ms Govender, suspended in February 2025, have yet to be finalised. Magistrate Govender was recommended for dismissal by the Magistrates Commission in 2024 after being found guilty of misconduct. However, the findings were later overturned following a court review, halting the dismissal process. She remains on provisional suspension, with the committee proposing that the National Assembly should not recommend her reinstatement to office.

The committee further supported the proposed reforms – stronger measures to ensure magistrates are held accountable for misconduct. The committee also mentioned plans to inform the Legal Practice Council whenever magistrates resign before facing disciplinary action. It also mentioned plans to establish a database to ensure magistrates are not subsequently appointed to acting judicial positions.

The committee also undertook to consult the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development on possible ways of recovering salaries paid to magistrates during suspension if they are found guilty of misconduct.

Mr Nqola said the committee will closely monitor developments and urged the Magistrates Commission to act with urgency.

Rajaa Azzakani
20 November 2026